New post
AllAccepted answers
Robert Cemper · Dec 27, 2017

My sample took somewhat longer to prepare then Edward's smiley and Gerd's

#1) to evaluate SQL statements use MgmtPortal/ Explorer/SQL and check the generated query plan.

#2) if you don't use special attributes to SELECT clause or sub-queries all SQL statements are strictly worked from left to right.
 your first statement is ok for SQL your 2nd is just a fragment that I interpreted as to be a sub-query

Summary: they are not identical.

Now the example transformed for namespace SAMPLES to have 3 tables as A, B, and C:

select A.id,B.id,c.Id from
    sample.person A left join 
    sample.employee B on A.id = B.spouse 
    inner join sample.company C on B.company = C.id 
 

Row count: 100

Query Plan:

Relative cost = 4200
Read extent bitmap Sample.Employee.$Employee, looping on ID.
For each row:
     Read master map Sample.Employee.IDKEY, using the given idkey value.
    Read extent bitmap Sample.Person.$Person, using the given ID.
 For each row:
     Read master map Sample.Company.IDKEY, using the given idkey value.
 Output the row.
 

transformed to sub-queries:

select aid,bid,cid from
(select A.id aid, b.id bid, b.company cid 
    from sample.person A 
    left join sample.employee B
    on A.id = B.spouse)
 inner join sample.company C 
 on cid = C.id 

it is obviously identic ! just more expressive.

Row count: 100

Query Plan:

Relative cost = 4200
Read extent bitmap Sample.Employee.$Employee, looping on ID.
For each row:
     Read master map Sample.Employee.IDKEY, using the given idkey value.
    Read extent bitmap Sample.Person.$Person, using the given ID.
 For each row:
     Read master map Sample.Company.IDKEY, using the given idkey value.
 Output the row.

the next  LEFT_JOIN(A,INNER_JOIN(B.C))  requires immediate transformation

select A.id,bid,cid from
sample.person A left join
(select b.id as bid,c.id cid, b.spouse bsp 
 from sample.employee B
 inner join sample.company C on B.company = C.id) 
 on A.id = bsp

Row count:  237  (!!!!)

Query Plan:

Relative cost = 32408
Read extent bitmap Sample.Person.$Person, looping on ID.
For each row:
 Call module E.
 Read temp-file A, using the given VIEW column #3, and looping on VIEW counter.
 For each row:
 Generate a row padded with NULL for the view if no row qualified.
 Output the row.
module E
Read extent bitmap Sample.Employee.$Employee, looping on ID.
For each row:
 Read master map Sample.Employee.IDKEY, using the given idkey value.
 Read master map Sample.Company.IDKEY, using the given idkey value.
 Increment view row counter.
 Add a row to temp-file A, subscripted by VIEW column #3 and VIEW counter,
 with node data of VIEW column #1 and VIEW column #2.

So both variants are possible though the result is different

HTH,

Robert Cemper · Dec 26, 2017

the key difference is that you can pass the classname by a variable.
So you are prepared to get the classname passed by some other method.

In your example with a constant string"circle"you miss the key advantage and It's of o added value.

BTW. Correct is   $classmethod("circle.radius","%New")

http://docs.intersystems.com/latest/csp/docbook/DocBook.UI.Page.cls?KEY=...

Robert Cemper · Dec 22, 2017

For testing with Terminal I typically use PuTTY.  http://www.putty.org/

There I can have multiple terminals with separated  Sessions/$JOB in parallel without problem.
(pls. don't ask how )
Terminal driver changes to a free set of ports ( 51133|10088) as you see by $IO
so it's no problem to have multiple terminal sessions connected 

USER>w $io
|TNT|127.0.0.1:51133|10088

I have no idea if Atelier allows multiple Terminals . And if how to launch them.
In Atelier just click again to the Terminal Open Icon:

Robert Cemper · Dec 21, 2017

Right: if you don't establish TELNET connection it's just bash or MS-DOS depending on your local OS.
Also for local localhost access !
so from Help:

Using the Terminal Plug-in
Telnet Connection
If your Caché instance is on a remote Windows server, you will need to connect using Telnet.
  1. Enable %Service_Telnet from the Management Portal (http:///csp/sys/sec/%25CSP.UI.Portal.Services.zen)
  2. In the main menu, select Show View > Other > Terminal > Terminal, or click this link to open the Opens the new Class file wizard Terminal View.
  3. Select the Open a Terminal button on the Terminal view toolbar.
  4. Select Telnet Terminal from the Choose terminal drop down menu.
  5. Complete the Telnet session configuration and click "OK"
  6. If csession isn't in your PATH, navigate to your instance's bin directory. For example, cd C:\InterSystems\Cache\bin.
  7. Launch a Caché terminal session. For example, csession Cache.

Setup Connection

And you get your Caché Terminal

 

HTH

Robert Cemper · Dec 20, 2017

It is. I have used it some time ago.
You need a  suitable plug in and connect to port 23 of your server 
(provided it is not blocked by Win* firewall.

plugin from the following update repository: http://download.eclipse.org/tm/terminal/marketplace/.

  1. From your Eclipse/Atelier workspace, navigate to command link Help > Install New Software from the main menu.
  2. Enter the URL for the Terminal plugin update site in the Work with field. Ensure that the Group items by category check box is selected.
  3. Once the groups are displayed, select the check box by the newest version.
  4. Click Next to open the Install Details page. Review your installation choices.
  5. Click Next to open the Review Licenses page. Accept the license terms and click Finish.
  6. To open the Terminal view, select Window > Show View > Other on the main menu and type "terminal" in the filter box. Select Terminal and OK.
Robert Cemper · Dec 20, 2017

Because it's so easy I've added a solution for those readers that don't refuse to work with Caché Objects & Classes .

Class Definition

Class DC.productListing Extends (%RegisteredObject, %XML.Adaptor)                            
{                                                                                                                                                                          
Property product As %String(CONTENT = "MIXED", XMLPROJECTION = "CONTENT");
}                                                                                                                                                                          

Simple display method

ClassMethod Show(xml As %String(MAXLEN=""))
{
 set rd=##class(%XML.Reader).%New()
    ,sc=rd.OpenString(xml)
 do rd.Correlate("product","DC.productListing")
 while rd.Next(.obj) {
    write !,"######"_$i(cnt)_"#########",$replace(obj.product,$c(10),$C(13,10))
 }
}

Extended test data

USER>write xml
<productListing title="ABC Products">
 <product>
   <name>Product One</name>
   <description>Product One is an exciting new widget that will simplify your life.</description>
   <cost>$19.95</cost>
   <shipping>$2.95</shipping>
 </product>
 <product>
   <name>Product 2</name>
   <description>Product 2 is an exciti</description>
   <cost>$19.95</cost>
   <shipping>$2.95</shipping>
 </product>
 <product>
   <name>Product 3</name>
   <description>Product 3 is simplify your life.</description>
   <cost>$19.95</cost>
   <shipping>$2.95</shipping>
 </product>
</productListing>
USER>

Result

USER>do ##class(DC.productListing).Show(xml)
 
######1#########
  <name>Product One</name>
  <description>Product One is an exciting new widget that will simplify your life.</description>
  <cost>$19.95</cost>
  <shipping>$2.95</shipping>
 
######2#########
  <name>Product 2</name>
  <description>Product 2 is an exciti</description>
  <cost>$19.95</cost>
  <shipping>$2.95</shipping>
 
######3#########
  <name>Product 3</name>
  <description>Product 3 is simplify your life.</description>
  <cost>$19.95</cost>
  <shipping>$2.95</shipping>
 
USER>
Robert Cemper · Dec 18, 2017

Kevin,

if you call a ClassMethod() it will return whatever the type of return value is like.
some variants:

- your Classmethod generates the CSV file as you do and the return value is the filename

ClassMethod Kevin1() as %String [SqlProc]
{                                        
....... generate CVS File                
 quit Filename                           
}                                        

 

- instead of a file you generate a 2 dimensional $Piece String (, as field separator and ^ as record separator)

ClassMethod Kevin2() as %String(MAXLEN="") [SqlProc]
{                                                   
....... setup ResultSet                             
    set output=""                                   
    while rs.Next() {                               
        for col=1:1:rcws.GetColumnCount() { set output=output_rs.GetData(col)_"," }
        set output=output_"^"                       
        }                                           
    quit output                                     
}                                                   

 

- a similar thing could be rows as a list of JSON sets

ClassMethod Kevin3() as %String(MAXLEN="") [SqlProc]
{                                                   
    set output=""
    &SQL( SELECT LIST(line) into :output FROM (
             Select top 3 JSON_OBJECT('Name':Name
                                      ,'ZIP':Home_ZIP
                                      ,'State':Home_State) as line
                      from sample.Person where name [ 'A' )
             )
         )                                      
    quit output                                     
} 
///  {"Name":"Xiang,Agnes O.","ZIP":56604,"State":"MT"},{"Name":"Zubik,Bill A.","ZIP":78872,"State":"NV"},"Name":"Schaefer,Alvin X.","ZIP":63607,"State":"ME"}                                                 

in all cases you have to disassemble the result on the EXCEL end.

BUT as this is MS-EXCEL

my personal preference would be anyhow  to connect to Cache over ODBC with a local DSN
and just call your data via SQL and get back a full working XLS table that feeds the rest in your XLS.
This is standard in EXCEL and except for the DSN the same for ACCESS  or real DBs.
(as I don't own and use EXCEL any more  I can't offer an example)

- your initial question didn't mention CSV nor MS-EXCEL
so my Article on Light weight EXCEL Download may apply
https://community.intersystems.com/post/light-weight-excel-download

or  Tips & Tricks - SQL to Excel
https://community.intersystems.com/post/tips-tricks-sql-excel

HTH,
Robert