Arthematic overflow only on one server- mssql sql

When running a sql insert query with CONVERT('datetime', '2023-12-12 11:27:00',120) in an insert statement into a table this works on one server and not the other. 

i.e. to record datetimereceived 

Property datetimereceived As %TimeStamp(EXTERNALSQLNAME = "date_time_received", EXTERNALSQLTYPE = 93) [ SqlColumnNumber = 12, SqlFieldName = date_time_received ];

The gateway connections are the same, The one that works runs a v6 SQL server db the one that doesn't is the standard version 10 so although there is a mismatch i do not believe it would be this as the older setup works

Has anyone come across this

[SQLCODE: <-400>:<Fatal error occurred>]

  [%msg: < SQLState: (22003) NativeError: [8115] Message: [Microsoft][ODBC SQL Server Driver][SQL Server]Arithmetic overflow error converting expression to data type datetime. >]